From: Sarah, Mirfield - 24 Jul 2010 Fever of the Bone

FANTASTIC from beginning to end Fever of the bone has been my favourite book so far, although I have not read them all in the right order, it was easy to follow the book. Fantastically written and has you guessing every step of the way. The different stories of the characters was interesting to read, where they were, what they were doing, the ending was a killer, leaving it at such a point, HURRY UP AND BRING THE NEXT ONE OUT! haha I love it and can't wait to back read the one's I missed. THANK YOU for the awesomly great books!

From: Renee Doruyter, Vancouver BC, Canada - 23 Jun 2010 Fever of the Bone

This could be the best one yet! I've been watching and waiting for more about Dr. Tony Hill and DCI Carol Jordan and here it is, a truly fascinating tale that had me ignoring food, sleep and the rest of my life. I am in awe of Val McDermid's ability to work up riveting plots, believable characters, unrelenting suspense and satisfying conclusions. The Wire in the Blood TV series turned me on to this outstanding author and I've now bought and read almost all her books (there are three I'm still looking for) and I can't wait for the next one. Live long and prosper, Ms McDermid, and please keep writing!

From: Thoufeeq, Male', Maldives - 23 May 2010 The Mermaids Singing

Excellent Thriller!! This was my first book that i have read of hers. I found it in the library and liked the synopses on the back... This book has all the necessary ideas, characters, guess points..where i suspect someone else...and most of all is full of action..never a quiet moment..to be bored... An excellent Read!! Now am reading Fever of the Bone!!

From: Deb Jorgensen, Minneapolis, MN, USA - 25 Nov 2009 A Place of Execution

BEST NEW MYSTERY AUTHOR I'VE READ! I had never read Val McDermid before until this book was recommmended by a mystery bookstore in Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA. I thought it had more twists and turns in the plot and wonderful characters delineated than any book I'd read in 10 years. She is my hero and I have read the Tony Hill series and some of her later books. I have a degree in English literature in the States and feel that she deserves to be read by even the pickiest mystery readers.

From: anna, Sussex - 22 Oct 2009 The Distant Echo

Addictive This was the first book of Val McDermids that I read, I couldn't put it down! The end had such a twist that it still sticks in my brain now and I finished the book back in April!! That started the addicition and I get withdrawl symptoms if I haven't read one of the books for a while.

From: maria, stockport - 18 Oct 2009 Blue Genes

felt much more of a personal voice Already familiar with Val McDermid books, I had read several, watched Tony Hill (Rob) in action on tv, and recently read a 'double' 2-in1 of Blue Genes and Clean Break. I was delighted by them both, great characters and fast-paced, but with a very different feel to later work. The language here and there was more 'northern' and the writing slightly less polished but in a way more real. I felt that I was hearing more of the 'writer's voice' in these two, which to me is a good thing! Like with music, I love to get those glimpses of something approaching the soul of the artist. It helps of course that I am familiar with the areas used in the book, Stockport and Manchester - I even did a short stint as an 80's music journalist, though not on the scale of KB's partner in the books. The reference to Manchester's flyposting wars triggered a few memories! Whilst I loved the storytelling, they made me more intrigued about the author too, checking the copyright dates and more eager to see the path that the writing has taken over the years. I will now be tracking down other books from this era and definitely keeping a fuller 'Val' section in my bookcase!

From: Shirley Lyn Ward, Staffordshire - 04 Oct 2009 The Grave Tattoo

I was truly surprised a non-Tony Hill could keep me as engaged as this did!! I have to say first and foremost I LOVE the Tony Hill books, dont like Val's other serial characters at all (Lindsay Gordon - awful), and so came to Grave Tattoo with an expectation that I wouldnt like it. How wrong can you be, I thought it was brilliant. Great new heroine that she could def use again, thought the swing between present day and Fletcher Christian's era was inspired. Totally different from Hill/Jordan, and if like me you thought it didnt get any better, please try this, you wont be disappointed!

From: Geoff Kilner, Newcastle upon Tyne, England - 24 Sep 2009 A Darker Domain

good read-strong characters Catches the bitterness of the miner's strike though I never saw that much poverty in South Yorkshire at the time.I like the Greek tragedy element, sins playing out down the generations in Brodie's family.Excellent location descriptions of Fife,the coast and Tuscany. As a male reader, it's good to see a well-written thriller with so many strong women characters.Will definitely read more of her tales.

From: Bryan Gifford, Greenwich, OH - 12 Sep 2009 The Last Temptation

As Joanna said This is a great book, and Id like to talk more in detail about her views of what the author was getting to. Call me sometime... 419-295-5009... It's been a long time, I didnt think we'd ever talk again.

From: Joanna Meadows, Richmond, Virginia, USA - 17 Aug 2009 Killing The Shadows

Another one that kept me reading into the wee hours. "Killing The Shadows" is the second of Val's books that I've read. "Place of Execution" is still my favorite, but I liked this one almost as much, and stayed up way past my bedtime to keep reading. I now have a long list of McDermid books on my request list at the library. (Sorry that my limited income means I can't afford to contribute by buying them, but I'm passing the word to all my women friends.)

From: Joanna Meadows, Richmond, Virginia, USA - 15 Aug 2009 A Place of Execution

Best book I've read in months! "A Place of Execution" is the first of Val's books that I've read, and I just finished it late last night. The anxiety of not knowing how it would end tried my patience to keep reading and not turn to the back of the book (something my ex-partner used to do routinely, which drove me crazy!) I resisted the temptation, and was rewarded beyond my expectations! I am currently recommending this book to every woman I know, and looking forward to reading more of Val's books.

From: sam, Bristol - 31 Jul 2009 A Darker Domain

reminded me of the bad old days This book brought the 1980 back to me as if it were yesterday. A great account of what it was like...

From: wavey, mansfield, england - 12 Jun 2009 A Darker Domain

Real Quality... enjoyed the book very much, a true reflection of a mining village and the difficulties within during the strike. the only thing i was a little annoyed with was the ending because i wanted to see justice done, but as always a very well written book..excellent for the beach

From: Julie, England - 02 Jun 2009 A Darker Domain

Great Read Got this book last week, couldn't put it down...

From: mia, Tipperary, Ireland - 24 May 2009 A Darker Domain

all consuming... had 3 hour baths so that I could read in peace and at length! as ever with her books it starts simply and slowly with the beautiful intro to her main characters. This book in particular, jumped seemlessly between decades, threw you back (if you're old enough to remember)to a time that was a woebegotten one in English history. The twists and turns and fearless approach to the characters added to the story's intrigue. And the final twist was a most wonderful "nail in the coffin". I first discovered Val's books in a 2nd hand shop in Toronto, Canada in 2004 and have pretty much read them all since. They never disappoint and are never predictable... such is the joy of reading this author's work...

From: di, englandnorfolk - 23 Apr 2009 The Torment of Others

brilliant read first time i have read her books what a read couldnt put it down..must get another one

From: Tony Alleeson, Worcestershire, England - 27 Jan 2009 The Wire In The Blood

Chilling to the very last line of the epilogue. Lesser writers seek to captivate their readers from the first paragraph. Val McDermid is a far superior writer than that. This plot is woven with unusual intelligence that proves all the more satisfying as it's shape develops and finally unravels into a gripping an compelling finale. There are well crafted interplays within this between DCI Carol Jordan, Dr Tony Hill, National Profiling Task Force, the Met and regional police squads and the psycholigical chess between Tony Hill and the chief suspect stands out. The frustration and lack of cooperarion between police and profilers gives a realistic glimpse of their work. The age and fallibility of the victims seems particurly poignant in today's world where so many crave fame and success. It may be unrealistic to suppose that there can and should be satisfactory closure after murders and in it's way, this book makes that point. I believe that this is one of the finest books of it's genre by one the most gifted authors who has been at the pinnacle of her career for quite some time. A first class read.

From: PiAnn, Helsinki, Finland - 31 Dec 2008 Beneath the Bleading

truly kept a veteran awake After two decades of reading crime fiction, I had grown suspicious of the cover blurb "will keep you up all night". Beneath the Bleeding was fully up to the challenge and truly kept me reading till the final page, feeling disappointed that this wonderful thought-provoking tale came to an end. I am hungering for more, particularly on the infamously tough Mrs Hill. Bravo for Val's courage to take on the Imperial Star Troopers!

From: schrodinger, Manchester - 26 Dec 2008 A Darker Domain

Very Disappointed Loved Val's other audiobooks but this one was just read too fast by the reader and I had to give up on it. Hopefully if it's brought out in unabridged format the reader will slow down and add some feeling. A disappointed Val fan

From: The Reader, London - 13 Dec 2008 A Place of Execution

a thoughtful read I agree with the general tone of the reviews for A Place of Execution but the book would have benefited from some serious editing.It was overly long and with a tighter control it could effortlessly have been at least 100 pages shorter. Its a splendid read though and it captures the period well .It has a strong narrative and the characters are well drawn although some are a little stale and paper thin and occasionally sterotypical- gritty policeman, witch-like rural old ladies and hated newcomers-which spoils the overall effect and atmosphere. The plot was a little predictable and the ending was rather a disappointment and far too drawn out but the writer was clearly heavily engaged with the characters and seemed reluctant to let them go. I enjoyed the book but it was simply far too long and often repetitive.

From: Lyn Blanchard, Scunthorpe Lincolnshire England - 14 Nov 2008 Beneath the Bleading

I kept trying to outguess the team but failed A really good yarn. having watched the series "Wire in the blood" I kept imagining Robson Green's voice in the script. Two questions for Val please. How did Rachel have the knowledge to presumably add or select "the third component (of the bomb) taped between the ignition and the timer?" .Yousef assembled the bomb but didn't have full knowledge of it's components. Also, could Val please refer Tony to a Psychoanalyst so he could sort out his emotions in order to have a long-term romantic and sexual relationship with Carol? Finally, thanks for the story Val, I will definitely be buying more in the series featuring Tony Hill.

From: Paul Bamber, Houston, Texas - 09 Nov 2008 A Place of Execution

Great Book, well written - until the ending! I loved the first part of the book. Very well written, great charachters, wonderful description of the era and the atmosphere. But, the end blows it. Too huge a coincidence that George's son is marrying Allison's daughter. Too many unanswered questions. Hawkins would have confessed to the other child abuse to save his neck. If he brought that up, police would have looked more closey at the possibility of the villagers setting him up. That said, I will definately read more of Val McDermids work.

From: TC, Kingston upon Thames, England - 02 Nov 2008 A Darker Domain

my first Val - need to know more! fabulous - never read her before, but this is unputdownable - kind of remember the miners strike but too young to know its significance - her writing almost makes you feel ashamed that you weren't as aware as you should have been - very pacy,thought provoking and gripping. Will be reading more, but can anyone tell me - given the hints of Karen Pirie's past, has she featured in other books? Can't find a mention of her in the synopsis' available on line.

From: Duffy, Northumberland, England - 26 Oct 2008 A Darker Domain

Left me disappointed A big let down compared to all her other books. Normally I hate to have to put one of her books down but this one I found myself looking for an excuse to leave it. It was very dis-jointed and I could not engage with any of the characters ergo I did not care what happened to them by the end of the book. However, I remain loyal to Val McDermid and will continue to seek out and read all her future books because over the years she has given me hours of excellent reading.

From: lizzie, melbourne aust.ex glasgow - 25 Oct 2008 A Darker Domain

val you are a gem just finished the darker domain. loved every word. nice to see a connection to an earlier book so that means i will have to read that again. keep up the good work. whens the next one coming out.

From: san, ashton - 12 Oct 2008 Select

i have read all your book they are all brill i cant choose a fave! i wait with open breath for your new books as i have read them all, and recomend them always your brill

From: Mary Meade, Vermont United States - 05 Oct 2008 The Last Temptation

could not find a place were I could put it asideand go about my work the in depth character of the people in her stories almost make it seem like you know them or someone like them.I always have my own version of the ending but hers always surprises me.

From: Lisa Marie Moorhead, Bedlington, England - 23 Sep 2008 The Wire In The Blood

Just started reading Val. Great ! Just finished reading the Mermaids Singing and have just started Wire in the Blood. I am an avid reader of crime novels and I am over the moon someone referred me to these novels. Normally I do not usually like to watch a film or tv programme before I have read the book but in this instance where Tony is concerned I feel comforted by the fact that I can picture his face and know his personality (whoever casted Robson Green knows their stuff). Cant't wait for more

From: Growler, Melbourne Australia - 23 Sep 2008 A Place of Execution

Totally gripping If you can remember where you were when Kennedy was shot, where you were when John Lennon was shot, where it was you watched the 1966 World Cup Final, well, you are obviously above a certain age. But if you can remember where you were when you read "A Place Of Execution", that recollection of time and place has more to do with the atmosphere Val McDermid created in your mind then any effect external events may have had on you. I can remember the streetside Restaurant I took to every lunchtime in order to immerse myself in that world, redolent of small villages in Derbyshire and the Moors murders. This ia a superb book and although I have read just about everything Val has written since the Kate Brannigan books, this for me is the finest

From: sally, Brighton, England - 11 Sep 2008 The Mermaids Singing

A real page turner This being the first in the series of the Hill/jordan books , thought i'd read it after The Torment Of Others. I really enjoyed it! It was good to learn the beginings of Tony's and Carols relationship.I have seen the T.V series adaptation, the book was by far more satisfying, darker and 'meatier'.I look forward to reading more in this series.

From: Rachael, Knottingley, West Yorkshire - 10 Sep 2008 The Grave Tattoo

Murder, mystery spiced with history. Val McDermid is a mistress of her craft, just as Rankin is the master. The Grave Tattoo, a standalone in amongst the great Tony Hill and Carol Jordan series, takes us back through ages to the time of Wordsworth, the famous case of Mutiny on the Bounty and whether or not a body discovered buried in the hills could be that of Fletcher Christian. I could smell and taste the air in the Lakes, so vivid is the picture that Val creates. I was so lost in it all, the ending crept up on me. I was sad to finish!

From: Can't do without my thrillers, Ballina NSW Australia - 07 Sep 2008 Select

I just love a thriller and am always more than pleased with Val McDermid's work. My only problem is finding books that I have not read yet? Am always searching at the second hand shops, library and book stores. I guess some are out of print. Can't wait to read 'A Darker Domain'

From: Marie Dangercop, Paris - 24 Aug 2008 The Torment of Others

I'm in love with your duo ! I'm a all new because i've read the books with Carol and Tony in only one month, during my holidays in july, 2008. I'm totally crazy about them ! silence of the lamb and seven are my "cup of tea" now i've got your serie ! thanks thousand time just one only regreat : the time for the traduction of beneath the bleeding : nothing yet for the moment !and it makes me angry !!!

From: sally, Brighton, England - 22 Aug 2008 The Torment of Others

loved it I thought this book was really well done . The story was a page turner. I liked how the different relationships wove in and out of the narrative.The characters were really well drawn, it was easy to imagine them. This was my favorite book of Vals so far, Iv'e only read 3!,but this has wetted my appetite for more. Pacey, gruesome and poigniant.

From: Farhan Ata Arain, Lahore, Pakistan - 11 Aug 2008 Beneath the Bleeding

Excellent plot.. wonderful climax! This was the first book that I've read by Ms. Val, and I must say I loved every bit of it. Especially Tony Hill's deduction regarding the killers. Just one quick thing.. usually Pakistanis don't keep the name 'Raj'. That name belongs usually to Indian families. I don't want to give out spoilers, so won't say more but the plot is fabulously knit and climax excellent. Will definitely read more of your work.

From: Alison, York, England - 08 Jul 2008 A Place of Execution

Loved the book, shame about the ending I put off reading this for a while because of the subject of the Moors Murders, but in fact they're very minor here and so all was well. I loved it, simple as that - pace and suspense and everything a good book should have. I found the ending a little bit of a cop out and suddenly very, very obvious, but up until literally the last 20 pages or so, I found it absolutely enthralling. Good stuff.

From: jellybean, wirral - 26 Jun 2008 The Last Temptation

best book i have read in a long time I have alway been put off watching the tv series as I don't rate robson green. However the book is excellent. The characters came alive in the text and but I couldn't visualise Robson Green as Tony.

From: balgair, scotland - 05 May 2008 The Wire In The Blood

Baffled and slightly disappointed First book of Val McDermid I have read. Picked it up on impulse in supermarket. I`m baffled or have I missed something. Exciting read but on reflection where is the use of DNA? Surely this should have been explored. Will try another one of her books but not a patch on James Patterson.

From: Betsy Gray, Ohio, USA - 23 Apr 2008 Beneath the Bleeding

Held my attention from page one. Val McDermid, Tony Hill and Carol Jordan just keep getting better and better. The story line is intriguing and Tony's thought processes as always are interesting. Nice touch giving us a peek into his background. And although you know from the beginning that things aren't as it seems, you're kept guessing until the end. I loved it.

From: seesthru, Pensacola FL USA - 21 Apr 2008 Select

I must read this book! I read teh chapter 3 excerpt. and I HAVE to know!! Is the child suffering at the hands of the grandfather Tony HIll himself? I mean, is seems exactly that way, but you never know with excerpts! If it is Tony who has undergone such cruelty as a child, does anyone cry for that child?

From: Malvina, Nontron, France - 07 Mar 2008 The Mermaids Singing

awsome! I'd not be able to read about such torture scenes if they were real, because they're absolutely gruesome. But as fiction, I have to admit I became addicted! I also just finished "a wire in the blodd" and ordered "the torment of others" : I guess there must be a dark side in me, really! But this is no reading for the easily scared.

From: Sonya, Alaska, U.S.A. - 20 Jan 2008 Dead Beat

Glued to the book! Its a very good book as it keeps you wondering throughout... There's one thing I wanted to confirm.. Actually I had to stop reading when I was half way through due to my exams and then I continued with some vague memories of what I had read.. I just wanted to ask is Neil the killer?

From: Angelika, Adelaide Australia - 18 Jan 2008 The Mermaids Singing

OMG! Loved it!! Like most others, I was gob-smacked by this book - started reading it on the bus home from work one night and put it down at 4pm the next day. Am now working my way through the rest of her work. Hope its not a stupid question - but does anyone know how the title relates to the book? Is it a metaphor for something?

From: V. Gruntz, Little Britain, Ontario, Canada - 06 Nov 2007 Beneath the Bleeding

Absolutely Fantastic! A wonderful read!!! The characters are so very real -- flaws and all. Fantastic plot that kept me guessing right to the very end. I've never read any of Val McDermid's books before but I will now be on the lookout for more.

From: kirsty, perth, australia - 12 Oct 2007 The Mermaids Singing

FANTASTIC.. COULDNT PUT IT DOWN!! WOW... WHAT CAN I SAY... I COULD NOT PUT IT DOWN AND WHEN I GOT TO THE END I WANTED MORE!! I HAD TO GO OUT AND BUY HE WIRE IN THE BLOOD. ABSOLUTELY FANTASIC BOOK... EVERYTHING THAT VAL WRITES IS WESOME FROM P.I KATE TO DR TONY HILL AND DCI JORDAN. THRILLING BOOK FROM START TO FINIS.. I LOOK FORWARD TO READING EVERYTHING YOU HAVE WRITTEN (HARD TO FIND IN AUSTRALIA) THANKYOU FOR THE GREAT READS!!!+++++++

From: Peter A, Derby, England - 26 Aug 2007 Beneath the Bleeding

A thoroughly enjoyable and brilliant psychological procedural Val McDermind gets better every time and so do her characters. Beneath the Bleeding is fresh, contemporary, cinematic and deeply thought-provoking. It's a big story, and the climax is a superb masterpiece of psychology, tight plotting and impossibly good writing. I defy anyone not to like this book. Tony Hill is far more expertly drawn in the hands of Val McDermid than of any TV director, and this book finally gives us some hints and revelations as to his past. The interplay between Tony Hill and DCI Carol Jordon is sketched beautifully and deeply nuanced in subtext. For me, this is the best book of the series. But it is both the plot and the prose combined that make this a must-read book. I could write that "I couldn't put it down", but that wouldn't be true. Sometimes I had to put it down to think about some of the concepts explored or clever phrases casually uttererd by one of the characters (on one or two occasions I admit to consulting a dictionary to get a word or context definition). The plot twists come fast and slick and there is no let-up in the pace. The procedural elements, which concern rank and masculine officialdom are enlightening and entertaining and the prevailing sense of justice carries throughout, as always. More than just a ripping good yarn, it's a riveting exploration into our deepest and darkest thoughts of envy and revenge. Spooky stuff. Lots of wry smiles and raised eyebrows from the reader at intelligent comments on the way.

From: Alice, woodsetts, s. yorkshire, u.k. - 22 Aug 2007 The Distant Echo

read it in a few hours - amazin this was the first val book i read n i absolutely love her writin style and the fact that shes local[ish] and writes in and around yorkshire. iv tried readin other authors but find none as gripin and brilliantly written, i have to now search high and low to get the books i havent yet read......

From: Davey, Holliston, Massachusetts USA - 30 Jul 2007 The Distant Echo

Complex, wonderful characters, This book competes with A Place of Execution (also by McDermid), as one of the best written murder mysteries I have come across. Four St. Andrews students drunkenly stumble across the dying body of a bar waitress, just before Christmas 1978. From that moment on, their lives are disrupted and nearly destroyed as they become the prime suspects. The story follows the four friends, as they attempt to lead normal lives over the next 25 years. They are hounded by the dead girls brothers. The police choose to ignore their stories (which are not completely true). They are frustrated at the lack of progress in the investigation. As new investigative techniques are created, the young men keep hoping that they will be exonerated, but lost evidence hampers the solution to the heinous crime. A secret held by the dead girls family becomes exposed decades after the original murder, much to the chagrin of her brothers. The distrust and hatred that wells from the small community has the young men in despair and it changes them dramatically. The best and worst of their character comes out, and others become unwitting victims. There are very few flaws in this novel, but even minor ones can impact the veracity of a well crafted story. In one instance, the murderer rents a car in California, but doesnt use a credit card. It is unlikely that one could rent a car in the United States without a credit card. Although the author might find a way around that issue, I dont think its a minor point. Part of the investigation involves a private detective, who might have uncovered some details that would have driven the story down a different road. The only other problem, if it is a problem, is that Rosies murderer becomes rather obvious well before the end of the book. How her murderer will affect the actions and eventually the destruction of another is not so obvious. The character development is marvelous, as Ziggy, Weird, Mondo, and Gilly, along with the detectives, and other associated characters, evolve into cunning, sympathetic, or pathetic figures.

From: georgie, Bonnie Scotland (aye right!!) - 11 Jul 2007 Killing The Shadows

Absolutely brilliant!!! The first book i've ever read by Val...got it from the school library...now totally on the look out to buy it and read her others!!

From: Stefan Vogt, Munich, Germany - 20 Jun 2007 Killing The Shadows

A one-night book There is not much to say, this is definitely one of Val's best books. The only sad thing to say is, that it is oviously not the start of a series. The described characters sure have the potential for a similar series as the one with Tony Hill. Maybe somebody tells Ms McDermid about my coment...

From: Peter Broadhurst, wilmslow - 17 Jun 2007 Killing The Shadows

once started, I had to finish it in one read This is the first book I have read by Val. I am now on the look-out for more. The plot was magnificently pieced together, in a manner that was totally credible.

From: Fred, Norfolk Island - 04 Feb 2007 The Grave Tattoo

Excellent whodunnit This is not a review in the usual sense: a few comments though. First, the characters seemed a little two-dimensional. Secondly, it was really curious that the author did not mention Norfolk Island once despite that island's close connection with the Fletcher Christian saga- even at the end when River had searched for his descendants on Pitcairn (logical) and New Zealand (reasonable- but there are hundreds of descendants on nearby Norfolk island). The interspecion of Christian's and Wordsworth's narratives at the start of each chapter was a nice touch.

From: Helen, Hemel Hempstead - 16 Jan 2007 The Grave Tattoo

Worth the time I bought this book as soon as it was published as I am a really big fan of Val's. It took me quite some time to get around reading it because I started the first few chapters a couple of times and lost interest. I am glad I made the effort because this is a great story and shows the versatility of Val's work. The historic angle was well researched and kept the readers interest, there was a couple of other story lines going along at the same time and though I did guess the outcome at the end one thing you can be sure of is Val McDermid does not resort to cliches. A good all round read but I cannot wait until the next Tony Hill book comes out.

From: Sue Marie Stevens, Phoenix, Arizona, United States - 04 Jan 2007 The Mermaids Singing

Could NOT put it down! Looking for a book to read-I hurriedly grabbed "Torment of Others" off the stand in a local drug store-not having heard of Ms McDermid. I was immensely gratified to not only devour this book, but, to get more of her great stories. I have a dictionary of British Slang and Colloquial Expressions which helps at times, but, even without that, I know that I would still love her thrillers just the same! I LOVE her stories and hate it when they end! I'm so glad that I discovered her-absolutely the best!

From: Reg, Singapore - 29 Oct 2006 Select

Fabulous! I never thought I would be spending time reading and borrowing books from the library every now and then. It all started when i found The Torment of Others at a book fair - where I intended to buy only comics. Intrigued by the synopsis at the back of the book and wanted to know what exactly lies in the book with such an attractive tittle (at least to me), I bought it and never regretted buying it. I borrowed The Wire in the Blood followed by The Torment of Others, not knowing i was borrowing them in the wrong chronological order. - They were, nonetheless, fabulous reads! The references to events that happened in the books before the one i was reading just makes me want to re-read them all again, and in chronological order. - Well, and when i get my hands on The Last Temptation. The writing, storyline, plot are just brilliant! Though I've fallen in love with the characters, Carol and especially Tony, I would want to read all of the books by Val. I simply love her writing style and I'd want more of Tony Hill books. I just love getting into the minds of the criminals, and in Val's style.

From: Margaret, Halifax, West Yorkshire - 28 Oct 2006 The Mermaids Singing

Harrowingly mind blowing! Found this book whilst on holiday and was sucked in immediately with the gripping yet horrendous detail that Val has written about. It kept me riveted to the last page and left me breathless and wanting more - even though it seems to be based around my locality, I was absolutely fascinated to the end! Excellent read, completely unputdownable! This was my first read of a Val McDermid book, but it definitely wont be my last. Would recommend this to anyone who can bear to read about the sickening mindset of novel criminals - er, it is just a novel - right?!

From: Highbrow, UK - 19 Oct 2006 A Place of Execution

Predictable In common with most of Val's readers, I conclude that Marie Marr, United Kingdom must be pig thick. "A Place of Execution" is predictable from the beginning and easy to see where the tale is going. No need to wade through the whole book, just read the last five pages.

From: Marie Marr, United Kingdom - 15 Oct 2006 A Place of Execution

an engrossing story. A classic crime novel, that becomes more enthralling as the reader progresses through the shoreline. Both the central and peripheral characters are well defined and believable, which the reader will find difficult not to empathise with.

From: Mine, Singapore - 30 Sep 2006 The Wire In The Blood

OK Good story, spoilt by bad grammar - no number/noun agreement, ignorance of possessives, incorrect use of demonstrative articles are just a few of the many mistakes throughout. However like all his stories Val never strays far from the pong of lesbianism.

From: Sacha, Kampala, Uganda - 07 Aug 2006 Killing The Shadows

Its Very gripping Well its a very good book..i cudnt put it down til i finished...its one of the best books i have read. It put in my suspense til the end..it had a good plot...i'm going to read it again.

From: sophie, manchester - 28 Jul 2006 Select

Couldn't put it down Another fab book from my favourite author. she just keeps on getting better!

From: russell, sarfend - 09 May 2006 The Distant Echo

Too long - and Val can do much better than this! Basically this is a whodunit of 561 pages, and I spotted who did it within less than 20. Normally I'm not that good at guessing such things so this has to be a weak element to the story. It removed most of the suspense for me, because I had to read over 500 more pages knowing the ending. And I was never in any doubt. A young girl is murdered back in 1978, and at the time the killer is not found although there are several key suspects, in particular the four students who discovered the body. Then we jump forwards to 2003 and the case is re-opened, with the occasional new twist here and there. What spoilt things for me was the absence of a strong, key central character. Previously I read The Torment of Others by the same author which included two of her most popular heroes Carol Jordan and Tony Hill. I think novels are made or broken by the depth of their central characters, and it's disappointing in this case because I already knew that McDermid is more than capable of creating them. The Distant Echo is compromised by the absence of any truly interesting characters and by its excessive length. Having said that I have confidence in the writer, I have about six other novels of hers that I have yet to read and I am sure that I will have more positive things to say about most if not all of them. Val McDermid is one of Britain's leading literary ladies and I can only suggest that The Distant Echo is a mild blip and normal service will soon be resumed. It's not bad, but not as good as her Hill/Jordan or Brannigan series.

From: russell, sarfend - 09 May 2006 A Place of Execution

Riveting, absorbing, entertaining and satisfying Val McDermid has written some outstanding novels (The Torment of Others, Wire in the Blood and Mermaids Singing come to mind) but somehow, somehow this one probably tops the lot. It is utterly immaculate in its (forgive the pun) execution, in its structure, in its characterisation and in its capacity to surprise and even deceive the reader. I need not go over the summary of the story here as so many others have already done that, but can I just repeat the words of the Daily Telegraphs Gerald Kaufman, who stated that It may be that McDermid will write better novels than this in the future, but I do not see how. I concur with that view absolutely. For those of you who remember seeing Hitchcocks Vertigo the first time, you will probably recall wanting to see the film all over again immediately, realising at the end that most of what had gone before was not as you had assumed. So it follows that in A Place of Execution, despite admirably detailed accounts of the investigations into the case of a missing teenage girl back in 1963, which in effect come to a seemingly satisfying conclusion three-quarters of the way through the book, the final quarter which unravels itself 35 years later in 1998 manages to completely dismantle our earlier belief that justice had been done and made me want to read the 1960s part of this book again to see if I could have guessed what was coming. Of course, I already knew that there was going to be a twist to this tale and I took much pleasure in taking guesses as to what it would be; a miscarriage of justice was the most obvious, but that cannot be said to be true because for all human reasons other than legal, justice was clearly served even if there were some unexpectedly high prices to be paid, it later emerged, on the part of more than one victim. This is storytelling at its best. The characters are so real that I feel that I want to contact them and talk about their experiences. I led myself to understand that A Place of Execution is based on a true story, in which case it only serves to underline that truth is invariably stranger and more convincing than fiction. There are some stories that just cannot be made up, and I reckon that this is one of them. Knowing the story was based on real-life events had left this novel on my library shelves at home for more than a year what a mistake that was, and I discovered this within a handful of pages. It has few flaws, it has been written by a masterful and confident writer at the top of her game and I recommend it without reservation. If you havent read it yet, then do not hesitate : order your copy today. And while youre at it, buy at least a half-dozen more Val McDermid novels, because in the world of suspense, mystery and crime writing she really has very few peers.

From: russell, sarfend - 09 May 2006 The Torment of Others

High Five It's always a pleasure when I take a chance on a new novelist and it pays off as well as it did here. Val McDermid is, I now know, one of our best writers and I won't hesitate to buy any book in the future with her name on the cover. In The Torment of Others, you'll get everything you want from a thriller and more : intelligent characters, gripping imagery, a powerful plot, clever pacing and just entertainment all round. The lead characters Jordan and Hill are very much individuals whose personalities and concerns are so well described that we almost feel that we know them; the key point is that we can easily believe in them. The side-plot of their 'relationship' is actually intriguing, dealt with subtle aplomb by their creator and cleverly left unfinished within the context of this story so that we can carry on where they left off in the next one. The main story line of this book is quite daringly graphic in its description without being gory for its own sake. It just leaves you wondering "Jeez, what a way to go"...and I'm not a woman! This is a writer of high intellect, vivid imagination and the bringing together of those rare skills makes for very enjoyable reading. Call me a fan.

From: russell, sarfend - 09 May 2006 The Wire In The Blood

Outstanding Val McDermid is one of the very best thriller writers of our time, and although I have only just finished reading this 1997 novel, it must rank as representative of VM at the peak of her abilities. Wire in the Blood is really hard to fault, and its one of the very few books that I have read that isnt something to do just to pass the time - no, its worthy of top choice on any list of means of entertainment. Cancel all appointments and read this first, its amazing value! Val is confident enough to name the killer on the first page yet develop and sustain tension for the reader until the very last one. Furthermore she has the ability to create and develop several characters that the reader can truly believe in, and build up a sense of strong like or dislike for more than one. The bad guy is one Jacko Vance, our feelings of hatred for him perhaps cleverly manipulated by the author by way of his iconic status as an adored public hero within the context of the story. The question is how will he be stopped? Fortunately his adversaries are the Hill-Jordan team, which might sound a little Formula One for anybody new to this series but in fact Home Office profiler/psychologist Dr Tony Hill and DCI Carol Jordan are in every sense a well-matched pairing, each with their own wardrobe skeletons and worthy of keen reader attention be they working alone or together. Its perhaps worth mentioning that Tony Hill is possibly the only male character in this story who comes out with any sense of respect or integrity, outnumbered as he is by several shining female roles. Even then, his potential status as Leading Man is undermined by his apparent impotence and subsequent inability to consummate the relationship that exists between he and Carol Jordan, who we assume has no such incapacities. There are more than a few lesbian references or characters which does call to question the accordant leanings of the writer, which I occasionally found distracting, but thats nitpicking in truth this is a taut, well-paced thriller that makes for a great introduction to anyone new to Val McDermid. I own all four of the Hill-Jordan novels but unfortunately I have read them in the wrong chronological order.just my luck to begin with the most recent (The Torment of Others), with its references to events in Berlin that I was yet to discover in the third in the series (The Last Temptation). Thats what Im reading right now immediately after finishing Wire in the Blood, and its every bit as good as the others. Val McDermid is without doubt one of my favourite writers of crime thrillers and I recommend her work unreservedly.

From: Trish, Townsville, Australia - 25 Apr 2006 The Torment of Others

BRILLIANT I'd seen "Wire in the Blood" on the television and thought it was pretty damn good so when I went to the book shop and found this book I immediately went home and sat down to read it, I didn't get up from that position for seven hours whilst my eyes flicked across the pages as fast as possible, needless to say dinner got burnt, the cat wasn't let out, the dog didn't go for a walk but I got one heck of a good read. The writing itself was brilliant, the storyline was great, twists came out of nowhere and left me reeling but most of all the two protagonists were realistic and compelling and real to life. Top notch, I look forward to the next Carol Jordan/Tony Hill book.

From: Sophie, Berlin, Germany - 12 Apr 2006 The Torment of Others

a thrilling book for a long night!!!!! After I watched the TV programm I wanted to have more from Val! I loved Wire In The Blood and of course Robson Green, but in German it wasnt as funny as in English so I bought the DVDs! but after I read the first book of val I was sure I wanted to have the others! I think the torment of others is one of the greatest books i ever read! it took me two nights to read it! the stories about Tony and Carol are like drugs: I just cant get enough of it! I really liked the relations-ship between Tony and Carol! and of course it was absolutely facinating to read! so keep it up Val!! Ill read every book you write!

From: Maja Bellash, Folkestone, England - 09 Apr 2006 The Torment of Others

a sad move away from positive images of women Having just heard about Val's being on a very short list of highly influential voices in publishing, it is a sad turn of events that her characters increasingly reflect stereotypical and male-biased views of women. Where Lindsay Gordon and Kate Brannigan integrate images of lesbian characters into their immediate surroundings in a positive way, in The Torment of Others, the reader is not only offered images of a lesbian police officer being tortured and who is the 'bad guy' committing such atrocities, another lesbian character. Not only is this plot line hardly believable, but it also panders to male fantasies about lesbian women and reinforces suspicion and marginalisation of them as a group. Val apparently commented on her being in such a powerful position by saying she had to be careflu how she uses her power. I would say that avoiding conforming to male dominated perspectives in her novels might be food for thought. The change in her writing over the years exhibits and ever increasing conformity to what the masses want than the innovative and radical visions of women's lives which, it seems to me, made her so popular to begin with. What price power?

From: Fridolina, Finland - 02 Dec 2005 The Last Temptation

Best book I have ever read! I have been watching the Wire in the blood-series on telly for as long as they have shown them here in Finland. And I think it is a brilliant serial. A few weeks ago I accidentally came across a book about Tony Hill and Carol Jordan and I decided to read it. After only a few pages I was hooked. I read and read and finished the book in a matter of days. It was thrilling and scary, but in some places it had a great deal of warmth in it too. It was the best book I have ever read! I will definately read the rest of the McDermid-books as soon as I can lay my hands on them. I recommend The last temptation warmly! If you find it, please read it, I promise you will not regret it!

From: goose, barcelona - 12 Nov 2005 Select

is davey kerr the same one fae sauchenbush?

From: shireen, india - 10 Oct 2005 The Distant Echo

gripping... an amazing read.... i have never read a mystery before but i couldnt put this one down before i finished it!! i recommend it for anyone who enjoys mystery... the killer was predictable after a while but the basic plot was too interesting so that blend in... over all... very interesting...

From: Paul Douglas, Australia - 30 Aug 2005 The Wire In The Blood

damage I have read the wire in the blood,I have read hundreds like it in terms of story,although it is well written,but my point is,how does a writer any writer of this type of fiction,deal with the things they are writing about,the torture and murder, of young women,in quite realistic detail to a more or less degree,while in reality it does happen frequently,right now somewhere a nightmare is actually happening in much the same way to a woman, so a writer doesnt have to make much up,but they are writing it for money and entertainment,I know one could apply this to almost anything and one might say,nothing would ever get written or filmed if this rule applied,but upon reading this book,it just struck me about our values,and particularly the values of a writer who deals in this stuff,something about responsibility to oneself and other people,wheres the payment for it,or who pays,and in what way and how,its not just stories,because it happens all the time to particularly women and children,are they the ones who pay inevitably with often their lives? So that writers can write,films can be made? We can be entertained?Is there a link somehow,one can say it would happen anyway without books and films.Yes thats true of course,but is it right or good to offer it up like this,even as fiction,when we know its not.

From: Al, Wales - 04 Aug 2005 The Torment of Others

A 'CAN'T PUT IT DOWN' READ Tony and Carol are back in this long overdue and very well written story. On the trail of another serial killer, they become immersed in a thick fug of complex and elusive characters. Amongst the murder and mayhem, Carol struggles to cope. Tony however, is at his manic best. This is a real spellbinder that I read in just two days. Absolutely brilliant!

From: Margery, Nashua, NH USA - 18 Jul 2005 Hostage to Murder

On my "keep till I die" book shelf I've always admired Val McDermid's writing, but have to admit that until I began watching the "Wire in the Blood" series on BBC Cable here in America, I did not really become a dyed-in-the-wool fan. I've re-read the Tony Hill series that I had read previously and enjoyed so as to be caught up in "The Torment of Others' in a proper frame of mind. This book is like marvelous icing on a very tasty cake. All the other Tony Hill books were excellent appetizers for this latest story. Val McDermid has become my favorite writer now that Colin Dexter has taken Inspector Morse to his final resting place.

From: Ian Banjer, Brisbane Qld Australia - 24 Jun 2005 Kick Back

Excellent Great read 1 of 6 in Best Reads Thiller Series Courier Mail News Paper Qld. Australia Read Kick Back Instant fan loved the English flavour of Manchester the characters and the plot cannot wait to get hold of another story

From: John L. Gibson, Ancaster, Ontario, Canada - 13 Jun 2005 The Distant Echo

I've found my new favourite author and not just because she's a Scot Move over Harlan Coben, Jeffrey Deaver, Jonathan Kellerman, James Patterson and Robert Crais. I've just discovered Val McDermid and she's my new favourite crime writer. While I had the ending figured out about two-third of the way through The Distant Echo, it remained an engrossing, couldn't-put-it-down thriller to the last page. From one Scot (and former journalist) to another, my congratulations to Val and rest assured I'll be buying everything she has ever written and everything she has yet to write.

From: jeanette romani, leeds, west yorkshire. - 01 Jun 2005 Dead Beat

fantastic, I bought the book as i was going on holiday, Just took a lucky dip out of the crime fiction section, Needless to say i was hooked.As soon as i got home i bought the full collection of Kate Brannigan adventures. Val Mcdermid is amazing, Im still working my way through the books and dont intend to stop untill ive read them all, Keek writing Val,

From: Craig Fraser, Haddington, Scotland - 19 May 2005 The Torment of Others

Absolutely Enthralling Having been on holiday I hate sunbathing and sitting around. However!! I got this book from the Book swap at the complex and couldn't put it down. My bum hit the sunlounger, in the shade of the umbrella, and i sat for 8 hours and finished it in one sitting. Never read a book that got me so involved so easily. I am a police officer and usually steer clear of work based subjects, however i find myself on this website looking for more of the same. Thanks for a thorougly enjoyable day in/out of the sunshine.

From: Hayley, Sheffield, England - 18 May 2005 Select

intreguing and frightening O wow! The torment of Others is Val's best book to date!!! I read it while doing some volantary work in Albania last summer inbetween teaching english and experiencing albanian life and culture and I really struggled to put it down. The plot is very surprising with some great twists, and I have to admit some parts did make me feel a little squeemish, even though I am quite unshockable so this book is not for the faint hearted! Nice work Val, keep going, see you at the lesbian arts festival later this year!

From: Rose, Adelaide, Australia - 11 May 2005 The Last Temptation

Totally Brilliant!!! Every Val McDermid book I've read has been un-put-downable. I'd thought `A Place Of Excecution' was her best book.......but I was wrong. I don't know how it was possible to top A Place Of Exec., but I'm only 50 or so pages from the end of `The Last Temptation', and not happy about coming to the end of it. I started it just over 24 hours ago, and have tried to make it last longer - like a kid with a new Xmas gift!! As with all the Tony Hill & Carol Jordan books, this one takes the reader on a surreal and terrifying journey into the dark side of human nature. I love the development of intimacy between Hill & Jordan, almost as an antidote to the references to the horrors of (legalised) abuse in history being carried down through the generations. And I loved the brief reference to civilisation being only a very thin veneer. This appears to be a recurring theme in all McDermid's books. I find all of her books provide a wonderful - if only brief - escape from the dull grind of everyday life.

From: Mick, Sydney , Australia - 10 May 2005 A Place of Execution

Wow , lost for words Funny enough I just liked the cover and bought this book a few weeks ago and to be honest I had not heard of the author . What can I say , what a fanatastic book , terrific style of telling the story and great characters . Looking at this website this novel is just the tip of the iceberg . Glad I've found out about Val what a lucky find , and now I dont mind my 45 min train rides home from work.

From: Holly, Co. Donegal Ireland - 04 May 2005 The Wire In The Blood

Wow! ok well i have a confession i havent read the books i cant seem to find them anywhere here in ireland but ive watched every single witb episode andi love it!altough it may ruin things for carl and tony to get together i do reallt want them to there so perfect for each other.and i love in the tv series the little moments they have its so lovely!i think the casting was perfect and i hope theres loads more series. i will buy the books as soon as i find them!

From: Russ, Australia - 21 Apr 2005 Killing The Shadows

Compelling and driven I love the genre and I appreciate the difference when I find a well crafted story. I find myself ploughing through. Time seems to slip away and the imagination is engaged. In my humble opinion Val McDermid writes with the best of them. She writes and engages my mind in the way Cornwell has. The bonus has been the settings in the U.K.

From: Jules Carter, Dublin (originally from Plymouth, Devon) - 20 Apr 2005 The Mermaids Singing

Magnificently written and wonderful characters! After reading The Mermaids Singing, Wire in the Blood and starting to read The Last Temptation (which believe me will not take me long)I am amazed that for the first time in ages I cannot put them down! The writing is excellent and you can imagine the characters as they are so utterly believable. The televising of Wire in the Blood was a very good move, isn't Robson Greene so like the character Dr Tony Hill? Well done casting. I would encourage anyone to read these books, though knuckle-biting in parts, are a thrill to read. What an excellent crime author Val McDermid is - we are all on the edge of our seats reading. Very atmospheric what more can I say? More, more and more!

From: Marg, Queensland, Australia - 10 Apr 2005 The Distant Echo

One of those stay up all night and read novels Riveting from beginning to end. Keeps one guessing from start to finish. Wonderful warm and "real" characters. Very simply, a book one just has to keep reading at the expense of all else.

From: loyal4, hull, england - 09 Apr 2005 The Torment of Others

couldn't put it down! it was fantastic! i loved it! i have read all of val mc dermids tony hill books and they have all been fantastic!

From: r, london - 08 Apr 2005 The Last Temptation

I hope she writes more after'the torture of the others' this book was terrifying, but the most exciting read. The characters are so alive and real, the readers can really feel their pain when it happens. I have never read anything like it before!

From: r, london - 08 Apr 2005 The Torment of Others

amazing, completely drawn into it This is one of the best books iv ever read, along with the other three before it. I only just discovered them, and haven't been able to stop reading them. The storyline is very exciting,also it's interesting to see it through the eyes of the killer. It's also good to have another storyline to distract the reader, and keep them on the edge of their seat!

From: Laura, Missouri U.S. - 31 Mar 2005 The Distant Echo

A Fantastic Read!!!! This was just a great story! The four main people in this book were so REAL!!!! Not many stories grab me like this. Anyone who grew up in the 70's will relate to these boys. What an ending! Kept me awake!!! Great job!!!!

From: Sandeep Harchowdhury, Mumbai, India - 23 Mar 2005 The Torment of Others

Gripping! There is no doubt about it at all - Val McDermid is a master storyteller. I could not put down this book. I had a tiring day at work and knew that I had to be up at 5 am the next day yet the story compelled me to read on. She has created each character with great care. To me they are just as real as my next-door neighbor (and hopefully my neighbor is not a killer!) Wow Val!

From: sue, Traralgon Australia - 23 Mar 2005 The Wire In The Blood

fantastic I saw the TV series first and loved it. But the the books are much better,I have enjoyed evey one,I hope Val writes more for Tony and carol

From: Wiggy, Reading, England - 01 Mar 2005 The Last Temptation

Val Mc Dermid - Legend Put it this way. I am 20, left school 4 years ago, hadn't read a book since. Stumbled across The Mermaids Singing and have not put the books down until i got to page 531 of The Last Temptation. All i can say is that i can not wait until pay day so that i can work my way through the rest of her fantastically written novels.

From: Leonie Hutcheson, Queensland, Australia - 16 Feb 2005 The Mermaids Singing

Where did the last week go? I have just finished reading 'The Mermaids Singing' and 'The Wire in the Blood' I've been struggling to keep up with my "motherly duties" when all I want to do was indulge myself with the text that Val MacDermid has created. I'm so pleased I stumbled across these books. I love a good thriller and the books had me guessing until the end of how it would all pan out. (Why does a good book have to have a last page?)

From: Mike, Sebago, Maine USA - 15 Feb 2005 The Distant Echo

awesome A chance audio book i picked up and was totally taken in with the book. Could hardly wait to get back in my truck and listen to a few more sentences on the way to the local store. Tremendous story line,tension was almost unbearable. I've listened to more than 450 books and this is in the top 3!!!!

From: Linda, Capalaba, Australia - 22 Jan 2005 The Torment of Others

THIS LEFT ME BREATHLESS - CAN'T WAIT FOR THE NEXT ONE!! I have been a fan of Val McDermid's writing for many years. After I read the last Tony Hill and Carol Jordan novel I thought that it was sadly the last for them especially after what Carol suffered through. I was absolutely delighted to find another installment!! After watching the TV series (I had already read the books but still enjoyed the show) I found Robson Green and Hermione Norris the perfect actors to play Tony and Carol. So often when books are made for TV, the result is disappointing - congrats to all involved. The only problem with finishing "The Torment of Others" is I am left panting for more and feeling much affection for Tony and Carol. Despite what others say I don't believe they have to have sex to "complete" their relationship - it's obvious they love each other deeply!

From: debs, Newcastle,England - 20 Jan 2005 The Last Temptation

could not stop turning the pages. deeply absorbing.i have read quite a few of Vals books since i found them about four months ago.Lost count of the books ive read but this one is brilliant.Very dramatic,loved the international crime busting work.Tony & Carol what a team,they are like friends now.If you are a new reader please do not miss this one...you will regret it.Im glad i have found Vals books I hope that Tony,Carol,Kate Brannigan & Lyndsey continue for some time.Thanks Val,excellent job.

From: Jo, Coogee NSW Australia - 03 Jan 2005 The Torment of Others

I missed dinner to keep reading this one! Brilliant storyline and so well written I couldn't put it down. Thought it might last a couple of days sunbathing on the beach but no chance! I started and only stopped when the last page was turned. The only problem now, is how long do I have to wait for the next Tony and Carol book? Not long I do hope Thank you Val.

From: natalie Mead, somerset - 04 Dec 2004 The Wire In The Blood

Bring back the series of wire in the blood I absolutley love the series. Please bring this back

From: rachel, suffolk - 01 Dec 2004 The Distant Echo

the most thrilling book i have ever have the pleasure of reading i don't what anyone says about this book it has to be the best book ever, there isn't a moment when i can put it down, i whan to read it over over and over again, everyone must read this book!

From: Mary O'Rourke Mejlholm, Vancouver Island, Canada - 29 Nov 2004 A Place of Execution

Brilliant plot, I was hooked at the onset! Atmospheric. The characters work their way into your sub-conscious, you find yourself feeling their passion, frustrations,exhaustion. The deep chill of the winter nights work its way into your bones, the Derbyshire moors haunt your every moment while the brilliant plot unfolds. I have since been on a McDermid-bender, consuming unheard-of amounts of her writing til the wee hours. Fervently recommended!

From: Clare Smith, Greater Manchester, England - 24 Nov 2004 A Place of Execution

Completely bewildering, very original I loved this book, hard to read towards the end due to the content but a heartfelt and captivating story. I didn't guess what was coming, for a chnage, and there were no cliches or things you felt you'd heard before. It was chilling and really left an impression on me for a long time.

From: Maj, Wakefield, England - 15 Nov 2004 The Torment of Others

Brilliant read! I've only recently started reading Val McDermid books and this last one was a masterpiece. Brilliantly written, totally believable and in places stomach churning, glad I have a strong stomach. I found it hard to put down and the characters were wonderfully human and the storyline chilling, but nevertheless fantastic!! When's the next one due out?

From: Maj, Wakefield England - 15 Nov 2004 The Torment of Others

Excellent reading!! I recently found Val McDermid's books and have since read a few of them and can't wait for the next one! Brilliant!! The plot is so believable and you find yourself embroiled in it so much that you can't put the book down. Val McDermid manages to keep your interest to the end and yes, you do need a strong stomach but the storyline is great and the characters so human that you find yourself living the story with them, I know I did. When's the next one due out?

From: Sylvie, Canada...Qubec - 06 Nov 2004 The Last Temptation

En francais, le titre est: la derniere tentation...decu de la derniere page dans l'epilogue....``Finalement, ce fut Carol qui rompit le silence:....et puis plus rien d'ecrit...pouvez-vous m'indiquer la phrase qui n'est pas dans le volume...merci l'avance!

From: Louise, Halmstad, Sweden - 15 Oct 2004 The Last Temptation

Amagaad! I'm 14 and last summer i watched wire in the blood on TV. When I found out that that there where books about Tony and Carol I ran to the nearest bookshop and bought them all! Now I have read the last Temptation.I couldn't put it down! I tried to read just a little every day so it would last longer but it was impossible! Since this was the latest book that came out in Sweden I ordered the next one in English, I can't wait till i get it!

From: red, Preston, Lancashire(but I'm from Scotland, near where Lyndsay Gordon's from) - 11 Oct 2004 A Place of Execution

Best book I have ever read I know most folk on this site will have read this book but if you havent, go, buy it now, take a day or so sick leave. I was introduced to Val by my now sadly ex girlfriend and have been readin her compulsivley ever since. This is by far the best peice of writing I have been honoured to read, an amazing plot and the ending will leave you breathless. I cannot stress enough READ THIS BOOK!!

From: Linda Bambrough, Adelaide, Australia - 27 Sep 2004 The Torment of Others

Riveting reading!! Yet another brilliant read! Impossible to put down! Looking forward to the next book from Val Mcdermid! especially with Tony Hill and Carol Jordan.

From: Stella Barnes, Darlington, Co Durham. - 22 Sep 2004 The Distant Echo

My best holiday read this summer I was so pleased to read this after making myself finish the awfully tedious "Da Vinci Code" that everyone was raving about. Val Mcdermid is a master storyteller and I have read nearly everything she has written and I was a fan long before Robson Green popularised her books on TV.This book was particularly gripping as it reflected 30+ years in the lives of a group of friends who had found a dead body whilst students at St Andrews Uni. Excellent.

From: laurel, U.S. - 22 Sep 2004 The Last Temptation

My favorite Tony and Carol Book Out of the three Tony and Carol books I've read, this one is definitely my favorite. It helps to have read the prior two to be able to keep up with character development, although it's not absolutely necessary. One of the murderers has a original motive, one that's guarenteed to get the reader to think past the novel and about history and the future of humanity. Excellent book!

From: Katy, UK - 19 Sep 2004 The Last Temptation

Just Brilliant After watching the fantastic TV series "Wire in the Blood" starring the wonderful Robson Green and Hermione Norris I read the Mermaids Singing and The Wire in the Blood, but this book has to be the best so far! It literally keeps you hooked and I was just dying to read more of it...usually it takes me weeks or even months to read a book, but I read this book in 2 days flat! Now I can't wait to get hold of The Torment of Others :) Roll on series 3 of Wire in the Blood on tv as well - I can't wait!

From: stacey 'Jordan'!, Nottinghamshire, England - 25 Aug 2004 The Torment of Others

tony and carol! sooo good!! I'd just like to say how much i loved this book! In fact all the Tony and Carol books that Val has done are amazing! Thought this one in particular really got me hooked and i loved the twist at the end! who would of guessed the killer other than good old Tony Hill! And is anyone else dieing for Carol and Tony to just get it on!!! there so right for each other and despite the fact i'm a lesbian i really think those two need each other and fit perfectly together! Thanx for reading, Stacey (a big fan!)

From: Maureen, Atlanta Georgia - 25 Aug 2004 The Torment of Others

Enjoyed every word! I love murder mysteries and have found that Val McDermid is the best writer in this category. After 30 years of murder mysteries, I do believe that Val is the best.

From: Emma Hancox, Warwickshire England - 06 Aug 2004 The Torment of Others

BLOODY BRILLIANT!! I have read all of this book and its really, chilling but the story line is fantastic. The story is told from every angle and will keep you gripped. Oh and you will need a strong stomach...or just dont eat before you read!

From: Lyndsay McPherson, Glasgow,Scotland - 03 Aug 2004 The Distant Echo

gripped by the plot! I recently bought this book and i was immdediately gripped by the book. For a while i never bothered to read a book but when i recently found one of Val Mcdermid's book in a book shop in Glasgow city centre i was hooked straight away and i felt the need to buy more crime novels by her. i think her writing is very good and this book kept me guessing the whole way through. definetly a thumbs up from me and my family members who read the book after me.

From: Carol Innes, Dartford, Kent - 22 Jul 2004 The Torment of Others

completely absorbing Another really enjoyable(?) novel from Val McDermid. I am in awe of her ability to write so concisely about such awful crimes and also in the cleverness of the plot. How does she manage to cram so much detail about police investigations and the work of psychologists in such a way as to make it so interesting and absorbing? An absolutely cracking read that I have hardly put down since the first page. It has interfered with housework, paid work, sleep and TV viewing over the past few days. It was so worth it.

From: Claire, Derbyshire, UK - 17 Jul 2004 The Distant Echo

Gripping read! This is the first book of Val's that I have read and I shall definitely be reading more. She writes excellently enabling the reader to be an active part in the lives and emotions of the characters. The tale twists and turns but never really giving you a clue as to the identity of the killer until the very end. You will not be able to put it down.

From: BIG FAN!!!, Sussex, England - 08 Jul 2004 The Torment of Others

How does she do it? I'm thirteen and stopped reading kids books 2 1/2 years ago. Someone at school picked up the last temptation and said: "my mum said it was good - you might like it!" I took it as a joke but read it anyway. I was immediately hooked on Tony Hill and Carol Jordon and rejoiced when the last book came out. I have to admit it wasn't quite as good as the previous two, but it was still tons better than any other book I've read before. I think if you've read the series you'll really enjoy (okay - possibly not the right word) this book, but you need to have read the rest. Once I made the mistake of lending wire in the Blood to my mother, but regreting it the second she read the first page. I then found her three weeks later reading it at night! Now she's as hooked as me but has a full time job so hasn't read the rest yet... I am still in utter awe of somebody who can create such believable, complex characters and plots - another stunning novel, well done! P.S. If you havent read it yet, you MUST!

From: Ross Janes, Bristol, England - 06 Jul 2004 The Torment of Others

FANTASTIC!!!!!!!!!!! What a fantastic read!!! This is the first Val McDermid book I've read since I started watching the ITV series - And I was not disappointed! And I can't wait to see how Don Merrick's death will affect the team in the next book. Well done Val McDermid, keep on writing! Can't wait for the next Tony/Carol book.

From: Helen, Hemel Hempstead - 30 Jun 2004 The Torment of Others

Superb I bought the Torment of Others a few weeks ago and had been waiting with anticipation to start it. I read the whole book in two days (I just forgot the children, the ironing etc). It was a really easy read, the plot flowed at a perfect pace with plenty of time for character development. I even didn't who it was until 3/4 way through the book which was amazing. I really enjoyed the way two stories were wove into the book with each being as interesting as the other. The only thing that stopped it getting 5 stars was the fact I am getting a little bored with the sections of the book about the killers thoughts typed in italic. They are essential to the plot I know, but so many authors do this now and its these sections I tend to skip if I am getting bored with a book. Roll on the next Tony & Carol book.

From: Tony Ellis, UN Cyprus - 27 Jun 2004 The Torment of Others

WOW another great Tony Hill novel Again another Tony Hill/Carol Jordan novel i could not put down, cant wait for the next

From: Jennifer Marr, Aberdeen, SCOTLAND!! :-) - 16 Jun 2004 The Distant Echo

It was brilliant, absolutely superb I have to say, without a doubt, that The Distant Echo is definitely McDermid's best book....I couldn't stop reading!! It was such a complex storyline but it was amazing. I love psychological thrillers and McDermid is definitely my favourite author. The book only had one flaw.....Ziggy died. I was quite upset when this happened as he was my favourite character. I managed to spot he was gay before McDermid revealed his secret!! ;) I thought this was an interesting plot twist as it created ideas in the reader's head. Overall a fantastic reader, I sincerely recommend it to anyone!

From: Ben Porter, Perth Australia - 05 Jun 2004 The Torment of Others

Disappointed with the conventional story line McDermid has never recovered from the Place of Execution which in my mind is the best book she has written and a classic of the genre. In contrast. Torment of Others is predictable and overdoes the 'girls do it better'idea. The lesbian direction of the novel with strong, independent and dominating women characters and weak, confused and devious men interfered with the creation of a suspenseful atmosphere and believeable narrative flow. Also, when will someone write a crime thriller where there isn't a boring, accountant-minded and insecure senior officer breathing down everyone's necks.

From: Laura, El Cajon, CA. USA - 28 May 2004 The Torment of Others

A Two Day Read I couldn't read it over night. I have a 2 year old grandniece who thinks I'm her favorite 2 year old friend. We will be 3 in December. But I would have if I had free time. I found "The Torment of Others" quite good. It was an easy read and made lots of sense. It made sense to me that Carol would fine someone to help her through the first steps back to sexual confidence. The story itself kept me guessing. I agreed about Tyler, but couldn't place who might have manipulated him. Tony's boss was my first suspect in the prostitute killings. When Honey ran after seeing Jan, then I started to suspect that the Creeper might be a cop. But Jan was too personable. It wasn't until the discussion at the kitchen table that I realized who it was. Jonathan was my first suspect in the killings of Tim and Guy. Maybe it was prejudice. He fit the profile completely and he showed up in her life and was very helpful just at the right time. And well, it always breaks my heart when Val writes that Tony berates himself as a worthless man. But he's got the answer now. Words without actions are useless. All in all, definitely recommended. I gave it 4 out of 5 stars. My fav is still "The Last Temptation" and I seriously hope everything comes through if Val and Robson get funding to do the film.

From: Rachellianah Laelah Coulson, Canterbury, England - 22 May 2004 The Distant Echo

IT WAS FANTASTIC!!!!! This book was honestly the best book I have ever read. I couldn't put it down. I had expected to read it little by little over the weekend but I was so absorbed in it after reading just the first few paragraphs that I just kept on reading for hours until I finished it. Val is an amazing author. Bravo! So well-written and such a good plot. And the morals it teaches about friendship and other things that are woven into it. Such a great book. I chose it randomly out of all the mystery/suspense books at the library and I am beyond the highest state of bliss that I chose it. I highly recommend it. It is the first of Val McDermid's books that I have read. I can hardly wait to read more of them!

From: Gary, Ontario, Canada - 17 May 2004 Killing The Shadows

Disappointing. After reading A Place of Execution I was looking forward to more of the author's work. I picked up Killing the Shadows and never finished it. The characters never came to life for me. When I found that I didn't care one way or the other if Kit lived or died or if the crime was ever solved I gave up.

From: Caroline, South Carolina, USA - 01 May 2004 The Distant Echo

So Gripping I read this book during an ice storm and let me tell you, it was so gripping that I didn't care we had no power or heat. I transported to St. Andrews all the way. Another facet of the book that made me come back for more, to the book and to Val McDermid, was I could put it down to do my school work, but when I picked it up again I was totally absorbed. Plus, I didn't figure out who the killer was until I was told. Bravo and an amazing effort.

From: Laura, El Cajon, California - 25 Apr 2004 The Last Temptation

Outstanding I guess that's all I have to say. It kept me going until the end and I couldn't stop myself. I got the book at 5 pm and finished it at 7am the next day. Laura

From: claire, bournemouth dorset - 19 Apr 2004 The Wire In The Blood

undisputible excellence The wire in the blood was such a fantastic book that i found myself staying awake til 2 or 3 in the morning as i couldnt bare to sleep without knowing the next chapter.After i read the book they actually showed it on the T.V but it was nothing compared to the actual story.it was truely excellent in every way.i was gripped from page 1.

From: Leah, Sydney, Australia - 18 Apr 2004 The Mermaids Singing

Val Mc Dermid pure genius!!!! i couldnt put it down so was so delitingly gruesome and so enthralling.i read it within 2 or 3 hours then went to find the next book . i read it in parallel to the screening of the tv series here. and i praise Mc dermid THANK YOU for writting it i'm buying double copies. i love my crime novels but yours definatly thrash all the rest!!!!!!!!!!!!

From: Sarah, Derbys - 17 Apr 2004 Killing The Shadows

Have become a serious addict!! Have just finished this book (my second of Vals books in the space of a week!!) What will i do when i return to work next week? A truly gripping read, my family know all about the plot and characters as i keep them up to date with the "story so far!" This book draws you in and then when you think you've got it sussed.... yet another twist!! Brilliant writing, highly recommended read, make sure you have no deadlines to meet though! Thanks Val

From: Laura, El Cajon, California, USA - 10 Apr 2004 The Torment of Others

Can't wait for more. I happened on the "Wire in the Blood" series with Robson Green and Hermione Norris and really liked it. I thought I'd check out the books. Books are never the same as the program, but I discovered that I like both for different reasons. Now as I read the first pages of the book, I can't wait for more. And also, I'd like for Val, the producers and the actors to find time to get series 3 going on the series. But I do understand in the entertainment business that time is in short supply. Laura

From: Patty Johnson, South west England - 07 Apr 2004 The Distant Echo

Mind absorbing Desperate for new reading material I found "The Distant echo" on sale at a special reduced price in a very well known national store. The result of this find is that at the moment I have 5 more of Val's books on order from Amazon. The easy flow of the words she uses and the twisting plot of the story is realy pleasing and entertaining. I'm Val's fan for life.

From: Jacqs, London - 26 Mar 2004 The Distant Echo

Couldn't put it down This was the first book of Val McDermid's I have read, it was fantastic. Everything about it was superb, writing, plot and ending. I will be reading more of her books.

From: Maggie Morris, Birmingham - 18 Mar 2004 The Wire In The Blood

Excellent Could you advise why the book is called "The Wire in the Blood" - any particular meaning to this. many thanks

From: Ray West, Charlotte, NC - 11 Feb 2004 The Distant Echo

Can't wait to read her next book This is a real tale twister. Val McDermid is a master at telling an intriging tale with lots of intrigue.Couldn't wait to find oiut the real killer.

From: arianne louw, holland - 30 Jan 2004 Killing The Shadows

great story I read the book killing the shadows. That was the firtst book of Val that i read. I didn't know her before, a frind told me about her. I read one page and i knew it would be a great story. And that was true. I am not a fast reader but is was done in about four days. It gave lods of pleaser. Thanks a lot. And keep up the good work. I can truely say that i love your work. greating from holland, your populair there to. xxx arianne

From: Pat, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania - 24 Jan 2004 The Distant Echo

What a surprise! I've just finished reading "The Distant Echo" and I could not put it down. It disrupted my work day, because I needed to get home to continue reading. Kept me on the edge of my chair until the very end. I will now catch up and read all the other books by this author. Thanks!!

From: Tez, Nottingham - 05 Nov 2003 The Mermaids Singing

One of the best books I've ever read I'm doing English A level at the moment and my tutor read a page from the book "The Mermaids Singing" and that was it, I was hooked so I borrowed it from him. I could't put it down, it is without a doubt the best crime book I have ever read! I have just finshed it and tomorrow you'll catch me in the nearest bookshop I can find buying all the books Val has ever written. PS, If you need me I'll be the one in the messy house and unkept garden living like a hermit for the next few months until I have finished every last one of Val's books.

From: David Collinge, Reluctantly in Nottinghamshire, England - 26 Oct 2003 Blue Genes

I haven't read another author since I've never read 'crime fiction' before but as an exiled Mancunian, reading the cover notes on Blue Genes, I thought "Well why not?" Within the first few pages I felt like I'd been taken home. I find the Kate B. novels exciting yet comfortable, like chatting with an old friend due to the familarity of the settings but excitement is added by then having surprises thrust upon you by the ability of the author to throw in twists that could not be predicted. Snipets of unexpected, laugh-out-loud humour only added to my enjoyment of my first Val McDermid read. I finished Blue Genes in a few days and have now read all of the 'Kate' books and three Tony Hill novels in succession. My favorite author has always been Douglas Coupland, contempary American fiction focusing on the disenfranchisement of the post baby-boom generation (X). For an author to divert me away from my prefered genre and make me long for more of her output before I've even finished the book I'm reading is testament and high praise indeed.

From: Debbie Hatch, Teesside, England - 14 Oct 2003 Killing The Shadows

Page-turner!!! This is the first of Val's books I have read and selected a book of hers as she was recommended on Amazon by readers of other authors I enjoy. Always sceptical about a new author I can honestly say I am now hooked and will be methodically working my way through Val's backlist. Killing the Shadows was excellent...the characters were very vivid and each chapter had me desperate to find out what was going to happen next. I read it in 5 days flat, infuriating my husband by concentrating on it when he wanted to talk about his day....addicted I'm afraid! Truly hope Val's other books are as good...I would hate to be disappointed now!

From: Di Bingham, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia - 12 Oct 2003 The Distant Echo

A very worthy addition to Val's bibliography The synopsis on Val's website reads "Synopsis: Four in the morning, mid-December, and snow is smothering St Andrews. Student Alex Gilbey and his three best friends are staggering home from a party when they stumble upon the body of a young woman. Rosie Duff has been raped, stabbed and left for dead in the ancient Pictish cemetery. And the only suspects are the four young students stained with her blood. Twenty-five years later, Fife police mount a cold case review. Among the unsolved murders they're examining is that of Rosie Duff. But someone else has their own idea of how justice should be done. One of the original quartet dies in a suspicious house fire. Soon after, a second is killed in what looks like a burglary gone sour. But Alex fears the worst. Someone is taking revenge for Rosie Duff. He has to find out who it is before he becomes the next victim. And it might just save his life if he can uncover who really killed Rosie all those years ago", which pretty much covers it in a nutshell What it doesn't cover is the taut plotting, superb writing (although gritty and realistic, not there to shock, just to paint the characters vividly) and gut aching suspense that makes you sit and read well past your bedtime - I do so love a book that pulls me in to such a degree that nothing penetrates until I finish it. Sometimes even a natural lull in the action is not enough to make me put it down, I HAVE to find out what's going to happen, whodunnit and if justice will prevail. This was one of those times. For all that her standalone novels can be darker than those of her earlier series like Kate Brannigan and Lyndsay Gordon, Val's characters are real and three dimensional and you care about them whether it's to like or dislike. As the focal points of the novel, I thought the whole quartet were beautifully drawn but I particularly liked Ziggy and Alex. And one of my particular favourite types of endings: I didn't have a clue what was coming until it was happening. It just adds that extra twist of enjoyment. This was as good as A Place of Execution, the last standalone I read, and if you haven't had a chance to read this one, do try it. Very highly recommended.

From: mindy, Nairn Scotland - 14 Aug 2003 The Mermaids Singing

fabulous!!! I got one of Vals books free in a magazine and enjoyed it so much that I immediatley rushed out and bought every book she had written.The Mermaids Singing is my particular favourite,and Ihave read it over and over again.Each time I read it I still enjoy it as much as the first time!Please can you write a follow up to it.

From: Kelly Walker, State College, PA - 15 Jul 2003 Killing The Shadows

wonderfully frightening I borrowed this book from a friend to read while on summer vacation. I couldn't imagine greater polar opposites than a sunny day at the seaside and Fiona Cameron's dark and dangerous quest to find a killer. Very gripping read indeed - right down to the supporting players and their side story. This was my first McDermid book, but it surely will not be my last! I've alot of catching up to do!

From: russell hawley, stoke on trent - 08 Jul 2003 A Place of Execution

so real you can smell it! A tightly spun tale, authentically set in the past, it is a story of betrayal and suspense. The ending will leave you breathless. Unputdownable!!

From: RD Larson, WA - 16 Jun 2003 Killing The Shadows

convoluted well-drawn plot and real time characters. I'm a fan of the writings of Val and have only just begun. I love Killing the Shadows, because the characters seems so real and believable. The tension never eases even though humor and good sense prevail for the characters. Also I must recommend "The Wire in the Blood" the television show made from Val's book. It's excellent.

From: sam, norwich,england - 15 Jun 2003 Kick Back

i need more brannigan I now have far too much time on my hands, five Kate Brannigan books is not enough, I need more!! Since reading all the titles when I talk about Kate to my friends they think she is a real person, I wonder sometimes if I do too!! This has led me to other titles by Val and not one of them has let me down. Stephen King is now in second place.

From: Alan Burridge, Poole, Dorset, England. - 14 Jun 2003 The Last Temptation

Exciting stuff When my wife brought the book home I'd never heard of Val. Now, after reading The Last Temptation I will most certainly be finding her other stories. What a writer! I mean, I write myself, but she taught me a great deal just reading her, especially the characters that have been crafted so well. I hope anything that rubbed off from reading Val will echo in my own books. If anyone's interested, check them out on www.e-booksonline.net

From: Sophie, Washington DC - 02 Jun 2003 A Place of Execution

A Classic!!! I read "A Place..." last year, Wow...what a story, well-written, nicely paced, exceptional! i made it my mission to read every single one of Ms. Mcdermid's books...i even ordered THE DISTANT ECHO off amazon uk, because i could not wait until october for it to come to the states!

From: Ingrid, Levanger, Norway - 16 May 2003 The Last Temptation

Disturbingly good... This is one hell of a book. And I absolutely loved it! I watched "The Wire in the Blood"-series this Easter and found that I simply had to read the books as well. And I have to admit, the Tony/Carol-relationship is what caught my eye in the first place. I love crime novels, and even more so if they've got a wee bit of romance. But this is just way more than I ever expected! I can hardly wait for the next book in the series...

From: debe, warrenton, missouri, usa - 05 May 2003 The Last Temptation

Gripping! Kudos for Val McDermid's third book featuring Dr Tony Hill. I have read the series backwards and found this book so interesting that I am getting all the back list as soon as possible. It is not off putting to have 2 threads going at once, and I loved it! VM brings terror to life with this series, and the deep cover to catch an elusive smuggler of human flesh is powerful, as is the ending...no spoilers here, but what the police "might" do in the name of "justice" is chilling... Highly recommend!

From: Ole Nielsen, Slagelse, Denmark - 25 Apr 2003 A Place of Execution

Enthrilled A week ago I made a not too nice review of 'Killing the shadows' (two stars), but 'Place of execution' should have 10! It`s just marvellous. The first half of the book I fell like I was in a dreamland. Extraordinary well written. WOW. Keep it that way, Val!!

From: Miriana, California - 19 Apr 2003 The Wire In The Blood

So gripping that it held on to me and wouldn't allow me to release myself !! I consider myself a layman expert on forensic/psychological/murder mysteries and find that this book is definitely at the top of its genre. Absolutely enthralling and touches the very pulse of what can be at the root of many behaviors. I even discovered a deep rooted mystery of a behavior way back in my teenage years that now I understand. The ending shocked me. I looked past the pages of an excerpt of the next novel to see if there was more to the ending. I wanted to READ..not imagine the satisfaction of knowing how Vance suffered humiliation and volcanic anger of being caught. I had to laugh at myself for looking further into the pages to find more..like a child thinking there was someone for real in the mirror.

From: Ole Nielsen, Slagelse, Denmark - 18 Apr 2003 Killing The Shadows

Far out......... I`m a great fan of Val McDermid. Having read all the Brannigan and Tony Hill novels I anticipated this novel. But no, this is one long irritating pain in the ass. Sorry Val. The plot is ok - it is a novel though, but I just cannot accept that one DCI, one serial-killer novelist (with a great imagination)and a kind of profiler all together keep on denying the threat until it is too late. It is not credible. This doesn`t mean I`ll skip forthcoming books. Still I haven`t read A place of execution, but I will. Anyway, Killing the shadows will be placed in the buttonshelf

From: Vicki, Stockton-On-Tees, England - 22 Mar 2003 Killing The Shadows

brilliant This was the first book I had read by Val and found it hard to put down, I have read such rubbish lately i.e The Wishing Game By Patrick Redmond, so this was a refreshing change with what seems like real people. Well done. I shall be looking out for other Val Mcdermid books

From: DO, Grand Saline,Texas,USA - 16 Mar 2003 A Place of Execution

Intelligently written From the Introduction all the way to October 1998 the chill in my spine never went away and my every sense of logic was mystified at the ending. Truly one of the best crime novels I have read in my life.

From: Kim, New Hampshire, USA - 12 Mar 2003 Killing The Shadows

Dull and expecting This was the 2nd book I purchased by Val, and along with the first I was disappointed. I enjoy suspense novels and crime novels, and this book I found to drag on and on and on...talk much about nothing..and as the first predictable. Unfortunately I was unhappy!! Crime novels are books you can't put down, and I put this book down several times and painstakingly tried to finish them....

From: Syrke, Moers, Germany - 09 Mar 2003 The Last Temptation

I want it now Hello there, please can you tell me when the book is out in germany? I couldn't wait anylonger; I love all of Val's books, but I'm sorry that my english isn't so good, so that I can read them in english. I look forward they are all comming to germany. Best regards Syrke

From: Suzanne Peters, Riverside, Ca. - 04 Mar 2003 A Place of Execution

BEST BOOK EVER WRITTEN!!! Once I opened the book, I felt as if I was there! A true masterpiece, I tell everyone about it. If your having trouble deciding on what novel to read this summer, make it A Place of Execution.

From: Alec Adcock, Co.Cavan, Ireland - 04 Feb 2003 A Place of Execution

I was totally absorbed by this story I found that "A Place of Execution" affected me; I felt moved by the denouement but also, strangely, Val McDermid`s strong characterization has you caring even for the less likeable characters. It`s a well-worn cliche to say "I couldn`t put it down" but let`s just say I found it a real wrench to leave off reading because the book is so well-written and crafted. I am now a real fan, Val!! I was born and raised in South Manchester; wish I was still there as I might bump into you!!

From: princess98476, East sussex - 20 Jan 2003 The Wire In The Blood

I find it hard to put this book down I think this book is different from The Mermaids Singing. Also it's different from the tv series. I think she should should write an update of this and put it on the tv. I heard that there's a new programme being put up on show leading from Wire in the Blood. Can you tell me if this is true and based on one of your books?

From: Jo Lane, Kansas City, USA - 14 Jan 2003 Star Struck

A real let down I guess I am new to Val Mc Dermid but I've read all the rave reviews so I was disappointed with Star Struck. The story line is so promising but it loses steam somewhere along the way. Val "cheats" i.e. she does not share all the information with the reader which is kind of unfair, right?

From: Pepsi Cheng, Southend, UK - 19 Nov 2002 The Wire In The Blood

Work of a genius!! Been reading Val's books since 1996, as soon as I finished the first book, I could tell that she was gonna be my fave author for a long while. I was suprised to see the dramatisation of The mermaids singing in the ITV series "Wire in the Blood", but watching it last week, they have lost loads of things that happen in the book. Her imagination is so vivid, I understand why they can't put the more gruesome details into the TV programme. Still it's enjoyable and I always thought that it would look good on screen. All I'm waiting for is to see A Place of Execution on the box. (Will be buying the new book as soon as it comes out in paperback!!)

From: Carol Lineback, Bettendorf, Iowa, USA - 28 Oct 2002 A Place of Execution

Our book club found it extremely interesting and enjoyable reading. I have been appointed by my book club to find out what the dedication (in French) in the front of the book means and to whom was it addressed. Please let me know. We think Val McDermid is a fine author, and we enjoyed her book very much.

From: Niki, Wiltshire, England - 22 Oct 2002 The Last Temptation

I really couldn't put this down even at crucial moments Having read every one of your books, I just couldn't wait to get the "new" one as always! Didn't think they could get any better, but I was wrong as always. I found some of the German references difficult to follow, but was not put off by this. Terrific plot, great to see Tony & Carol back in action! Can't wait for your next!!!!!

From: J, Australia - 12 Oct 2002 The Last Temptation

ENTHRALLING After watching the "wire in the blood" series I found myself needing to delve into Tony and Carol's minds. This book expands so much on the relationship tension portrayed by Robson Green and Hermione Norris. I found myself wanting to skip ahead and discover how it ends. But it can't end... We need more!!! Thanks to the tv series I can't stop reading Val's books (not just the tony and carol series)

From: stan mellor, calgary canada - 03 Oct 2002 The Wire In The Blood

excellent Conviction. Vance,+Donna Doyle + sex =DNA

From: Mollymax, Steinbeck County, California - 08 Sep 2002 The Wire In The Blood

How could you do this to me??? I read until 3AM and then couldn't get to sleep wondering what the heck happend to Jacko Vance??? Did I miss something...or, is there another book that will pick this up??? I'm catching up, Ms. McDermid, on the Tony & Carol books, which are just terrific, but have I missed a sequel somewhere? Just got The Last Temptation and am raring to go...it's going to be a problem however, because I can't get that dastardly Jacko off my mind!

From: Claire Nash, England - 04 Sep 2002 Crackdown

INCREADABLE!!! This is definately the best in the Kate Brannigan seris so far, I couldn't put it down from the moment i got it out of the library! A nail biting plot with unexpected twists and turns! Have subsequently got out 5 other McDermid books! Happy reading!

From: John Feaster, South Carolina, USA - 26 Aug 2002 Killing The Shadows

Intresting Sub Plots First read by this author... enjoyed the multiple sub plots which, in this instance, enhanced the story line. Very good read without excessive gore which often takes over a story. Highly reccommend this book and look forward to reading additional titles.

From: Wayne, Caerphilly, South Wales - 21 Aug 2002 Killing The Shadows

Tremendous read - honestly didn't know what was coming next A truly typical example of Vals work - i've yet to read her latest book but if its anywhere as good as Killing the Shadows i'd be pleased

From: Cynthia Roy, Indianapolis, Indiana, USA - 14 Aug 2002 A Place of Execution

Amazing story; great writing! In crime fiction genre, this must surely be one of the best of all time. I recommend it to everyone who seems interested in this genre. I'm so glad that I stumbled across Val McDermid! I'm now reading Killing the Shadows and cannot put it down. I read a lot of crime fiction, but there are only a few books that seem the best of the genre and A Place of Execution is surely one.

From: Mouse_78, Phoenix, Arizona - 01 Jul 2002 A Place of Execution

The BEST book I've read in awhile! To be honest, I have never read a book the way I did with 'A Place of Excecution'. I work 8 to 5 everyday and I read the book when I have some little quiet time and I can hardly get away from the pages. It's an extrodinary book that is being passed around the office by everyone. We all love it!

From: Marie, Northwest England - 29 Jun 2002 Union Jack

Read in one sitting! Fantastic book, once started couldn't leave until I had read the end! Characters were wonderfully explained and the plot had enough turns to keep you hooked. Very refreshing to read a book then read the second and still be hooked, usually is the case that the second never quite matches up...not in this case....! Now have to read the entire works of Ms Gordon! Also V McDermids other books......Will not rest until I do! Will be taking a stack on my Holidays.

From: neil marr, Monaco - 24 Jun 2002 The Last Temptation

whit rare, Stavvy Hi Val -- I've read them all. Even wrote you a letter a while back, but I don't think it reached you. Superb job of work on everything you've touched -- slainte and love -- Neil (now a small-time independent book publisher in the South of France) Marr. neilmarr@bewrite.net.

From: knatch, Hampshire, UK - 18 Jun 2002 The Mermaids Singing

Never has a book had such an effect on me! For the last twenty or thirty pages, I was covered in goose pimples, shaking and sweating, and jumping at the least little noise. This carried on for about half an hour afterwards. I have never been so thrilled by a book! Absolutely brilliant! (Oh, and you got the psychological profile of the average software engineer spot on, unfortunately.)

From: Josephine, Berlin, Germany - 10 Jun 2002 Killing The Shadows

Wow thats the first book I read by Val and I really enjoy reading it. I like the new psychologic view on crimes and the great main character. You feel involved by reading it! Gratulation for the author!

From: Menno, Den Helder, The Netherlands - 10 Jun 2002 The Mermaids Singing

Crime de la crime Three All-Time Suspense Classics: Sins of Omission by Gemma O'Connor, A Kiss Before Dying by Ira Levin and, of course, The Mermaids Singing by Val McDermid. If you see these excellent books in a book store, grab them and don't let go!

From: AliMarie, Chesterfield, England - 31 May 2002 Killing The Shadows

Best crime book I've ever read. I'm only 14 so when my mates asked what I was reading, they thought I was a bit gory, but it was great! It keeps you hanging on until the end, the final outcome being totally unpredictable, unlike most books I have read. Can't wait to read more of Val's books.

From: Nitesh Shah, Cardiff, Wales - 01 May 2002 Killing The Shadows

5 stars is definatly not enough A thrilling and amazing book, i thoroughly enjoyed it !!. This is the first book i have read by val, but definatly not the last, its so realistic and captures what we fear most ! i have always had an intrest in serial killers and criminal psychology and when Val puts it all in one book you couldnt ask for any more. All i ask is that she never ever stops writing! so go on buy it, loan it ..whatever just read it ! i promise you you will thank her afterwards!. It's a rollercoster ride from begining to end, you will not want to put it down at all (trust me). Its detail into the books characters is exeptional and plot wonderfull. feel how they feel ! just remember to take a few weeks of work because you will not want to eat or sleep, but only read it as it twist's and turns you all the way through. It's a book for all. And may i just thank Val once more for giving me something to look forwad to each night when i return home. p.s I look forward to her next book!.

From: Dave, a massive McDermid fan, Twickenham, England - 20 Apr 2002 A Place of Execution

Incredible. Didn't see the twist coming I quote Michael Connelly, when, during a recent appearance and book signing, he said, "this (a place of execution) is the best book I've read in the last 5 years". Enough said!!

From: Harsha, Uitenhage South Africa - 18 Apr 2002 The Mermaids Singing

Brilliant I have never read a book where the reader gets to know the killer so intimately. This book is absolutely mesmorising!

From: debbie sly, coventry, england - 09 Apr 2002 The Mermaids Singing

fascinating plot twist but almost too gory/evil A thrilling plot with an incredible plot twist at the end - certainly not anticipated by the reader. In places, almost too gory to read - really gets into the minds of these psychpaths. Rivetting stuff.

From: Anita, Australia - 07 Apr 2002 The Last Temptation

Unstoppable Reading I have read all of Val's books, my favourite being the Tony Hill/Carol Jordan series. The Last Temptation did not disappoint, I couldn't stop thinking of certain chapters, re-living certain scenes in my head for days after. Talking about it to people constantly and then the sadness of it ending with so many questions, so many thoughts of what Carol could have said to Tadeusz to hurt him more than he hurt her! Absolutely fantastic I can't wait for the next Val Mcdermid.

From: Amanda Fogarty, Manchester, England - 01 Apr 2002 A Place of Execution

Gripping Stuff!! What a fantastic read, I don't think you ever once took me where I thought you would, it was full of twists. I loved it. It spurred me on to buy more, I haven't read them all yet, but I have read Killing The Shadows, another excellent read. Although I did wonder what you've got against Paul Britton. Any time I'm in a bookshop and I see a book with your name on the cover, consider it sold.

From: Lesley, Lesley, Emerald, Australia - 24 Mar 2002 A Place of Execution

Totally absorbing and fascinating I have always been intrigued in the Moors Murders, so of course I had to read this. Dark and brooding in nature as you would expect from this backdrop and setting. The characters were very strong particularly the old matriarch, where I knew there was a story. Would have liked to know more about them in the finish but realise this was not relevant to the plot. The story was very clever from start to finish, did not want it to end, could not read another book for sometime afterward. This is my favourite of yours Val, a big challenge for you to come up with its equal, I especially liked the setting and the period. Could we have something else along these lines? I also loved Killing the Shadows with Fiona Cameron and the detective. Well done.

From: Roseann, Washington - Tyne and Wear - 28 Feb 2002 The Last Temptation

Val has done it again! Wow - What a fantastic read! As usual when reading one of Val's books no one can attract my attention, or get a word out of me that contains more than one syllable, (much to the annoyance of my nearest and dearest!),until I finally turn the last page. Needless to say this is one of those rare books that make you sorry it has to come to an end. I love the way the central characters have developed and grown over the three books and look forward to the next installment, (come on Val you know they have to do it!). Having two plots running side by side was engaging and a great bonus for the reader - like buy one get one free! If you read nothing else this year read this. It's dynamite.

From: JohnB, Marlow Bottom, Bucks, UK - 22 Feb 2002 The Last Temptation

Much awaited - does not disapoint The much awaited (by me) The Last Temptation was another great read. Although Im not overly keen on the Brannigans the Tony Hall / Carol Jordon characters are extremely well constructed and Im sure that Im not alone in trusting that they will eventually get it together. In fact the last lines of the book almost suggest this but with VAL we can never be certain how she will develop the characters. My only critiscisms (minor) are: I dont think that Carol would have gone straight to Tonys room after her near miss with Tadzio. She would have presumed that there was still a tail and gone to her own room, turning lights etc. on in there. They would never kiss where they could be observed from the outside. Lastly it was very convenient that Tony spoke fluent German. Sorry! Overall the book did not disappoint. It was good to have the atrocities of both the Stasi and the Nazi regimes brought into focus as a background to the action. I found the psychology of Will Mann very convincing, not that Im an expert in that field. The sad thing is that VAL is probably exactly right that the bureaucracy of the various Police Forces throughout Europe would react in the way she describes (No Im not a Eurosceptic!). Worst thing: Publication of this book means a long wait for the next. JohnB

From: Michelle, London - 07 Jan 2002 The Mermaids Singing

Strong story, strong characters and what an ending!! I discovered Val McDermid purely by accident, having been sent this book as part of a book club set. Being short of reading material I decided to give it a go and suddenly became emeshed in one of the most mesmorising books I have ever read. As a fan of Minnette Walters, Patricia Cornwell and Kathy Reichs I am a big fan of 'intelligent' fiction, where you use your brain as you read. The Mermaids Singing and indeed all of Val's books I have read, certainly come into the brain using mould. The book tantalises you right from the start, using excerpts from the killer's own log and introducing to the mind of a violent genius. The main characters from the policing side are extremely believeable, strong in their roles and yet with subtle human weaknesses beneath their tough working exteriors. Carol Jordan is a hard working female police officer, and her gender is never used by the author in a 'point scoring' exercise, merely as part of the whole character and the complexities therein, reminding me a little of Helen Mirren in Prime Suspect. Tony Hill is the psychologist, his knowledge and experience without question and yet suffering from real a human weakness - self doubt. Together in work they are wonderful to read about, outside work they both carefully dance around the edges of mutual attraction, each aware of their own individual doubts. The killer's character is a gem and I will not spoil it for those of you yet to discover this brilliant book. The storyline grips you from start to finish and leaves you literally praying for more. Some of the murder sequences are very graphic and yet I felt they were necessarily so and the graphic nature did not detract from the story. This book has no 'axes to grind' and is just a scintilating read.

From: Rachel Ives, Kent England - 22 Dec 2001 A Place of Execution

Wow! Watch out Patricia Cornwell! I thought the Mermaids are singing was fantastic! Then I read a Place of Execution and thought that was even better! It left me spellbound and thinking about it long after I had finished. Val McDermind is a genius. I am passionate about books and she is at the top of my best authors list.

From: BiblioBetty, a library in Ohio - 30 Nov 2001 Killing The Shadows

First book this year I couldn't put down. I picked up this book because I had enjoyed A Place of Execution. I normally have trouble tolerating vivid violent scenes but I really think the graphic descriptions were a must to the continuity of the story. In fact, I saw each book written by the victims not only as an important part of that writer's character, but each book was a character in itself. The character development was superb! Thanks Val!

From: nicholas, turkey - 29 Nov 2001 Blue Genes

kate's overcoming this is the book which 've already started reading. it's the 4th brannigan of mine. it's apparent that it brings you to the 4th so far. above everything kate's the coolest female detective i've ever read. it may sound weird to say such things but it's hard to discover any stuff like this where 'm living. i violently reccomend this serial to anyone who lost the fun and perspicacity in his/her life.

From: Trina Furre, Totnes, Devon - 04 Nov 2001 Killing The Shadows

gripping read! I have just read this book and found it hard to put down. I kept saying to myself 'I'll just get to the end of this chapter and then I'll...' but then just had to read on. I can thoroughly recommend this book.